I made this yesterday following the steps and using a hand mixer to finished and, the result was fantastic.
Thank you.

Carnation says:
Hi Angela, glad to hear that your Carnation fudge was such a success!

I made this last month - once finished I split the fudge into different lined containers added macadamia nuts to the base to some, rock salt on the top on a section and left the remainder plain - it worked everyone had a little taste of what they preferred - I'm about to concoct some more - I'm thinking a minted fudge at some point too !

Carnation says:
Hi Samantha, your ideas sound fab!

Can I use Flora instead of butter?

Carnation says:
Hi Moira, we normally use unsalted butter, but an alternative baking spread should work just as well.

Good Day

Do I need to use Demerara sugar? or will normal sugar be acceptable as well?

Carnation says:
Hi Nazly, you can use an alternative sugar to Demerara, however you'll get a slightly different taste than if you were to stick to the recipe exactly.

I used my Induction hob and the temperature was up there very quickly, tried beating with a spoon and electric mixer both worked out well, also I added vanilla scraped from the pods at stage 3 delicious

Hi love this recipe could I use Maraschino Cherries as an alternative
Thanx in advance

Carnation says:
Hi Carol, what a great idea! If you are going to add cherries, make sure you mix them in at the very end, right before you pour the mix into a tin for chilling. You might like our ginger and cherry fudge recipe on the website!

Love this, so simple to do...experienced cook but 1st time making any sweets. Recommended.

Hi. My fudge burnt badly at the bottom, was the pan wrong, or did i not stir enough, or what do you think i might have done wrong. Also to get a slightly softer fudge would i go only to 114 degrees ?

Hi Sara, sorry to hear that your fudge has been misbehaving! there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge - the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat for about 10 min. The trick is to allow it to cool for a minute before you start beating. Make sure that you use a non-stick pan and beat continuously to avoid burning the mixture. If the mix doesn't get hot enough, you might have trouble trying to get it to set.

Hi - can you use caster sugar instead? Thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Shannon, the colour and flavour will be slightly different, but the recipe should still work!

Hi just made my first batch of fudge do you put it in fridge to set?

Carnation says:
Hello, congratulations on Fudge success! This recipe will set at room temperature, so need to set in the fridge.

Can whisky be added to this fudge, and if so, how much and at what point?

Carnation says:
Hello, what a delightful idea! The best way of adding flavourings to the fudge is to add it in the very beginning with the rest of the ingredients. The fudge will take a little longer to get to soft ball stage before you start beating.

Made this but it turned out flaky for a fudge and the colour was not right. Looked pale. What did I do wrong? (Does taste good)

Carnation says:
Hi David, sorry to hear you are having trouble with your fudge. It is important to bring your mixture to a steady boil until it reaches soft boil stage or 118C. A good tip is to use a heavy based pan to ensure a consistent boil, and be sure to keep stirring, as this will stop the fudge from burning.

Just made this fudge, my granddaughter licked the beaters after I'd poured it into the tin to set. She said it tasted like 'real' fudge! I take that as a compliment!

Carnation says:
Hi Dawn, glad to hear that your fudge went down a treat! We always love to hear of Carnation successes!

Could the butter be replaced with clotted cream instead?

Carnation says:
Hello, the butter is an important ingredient to create deliciously smooth fudge.

How can I add some baileys to this beautiful recipe??
Carnation says:
Hi Michelle, you can yes! Just make sure that you add the Irish cream in step one in order to get the right fudge consistency.

Hello, instead of cooling it in a baking tray for, could I use a mold? (To make shaped pieces)
Thank you

Carnation says:
Hello, the Ultimate Fudge is best poured into a baking tray and then cut once cooled as it will still be piping hot even after the beating stage. To create shapes a cutter could be used before the fudge has set hard.

Hi, would it work if i used granulated sugar instead of demerera sugar to achieve a lighter colour as i want to make it a raspberry and white chocolate fudge,
Thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Alexia, what a great flavour idea! You can use granulated sugar, however it will change the colour and flavour a little. Let us know how it goes!

just done this recipe but it doesnt seem to want to thicken up and got to step 3 been beating for 12 mins now and help will be handy ??

Carnation says:
Hi Tasha, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

Complete beginner alert!
I made this today and I left simmering and everything was fine except I couldn't get the temperature up to 116oc. I managed a maximum of 106oc after 20 minutes only so mixture hasn't hardened.
Any tips?

Carnation says:
Hi Wendy, good luck we hope you enjoy sharing the results.

Can I use sweetened condensed milk instead of condensed milk?

Carnation says:
Hello Laura, Carnation Condensed Milk is also referred to as sweetened condensed milk. We hope you enjoy this recipe!

I made this yesterday and never made fudge before ever tasted amazing but it turned out more like toffee it a bit sticky is that right and if not cud some one help me so it doesn't become sticky on the next batch

Carnation says:
Hello Kelly, there are 2 very important stages to making fudge; the boiling and the beating. Make sure you boil the fudge to 118C (soft ball stage) and then beat with a spoon until the mixture becomes creamy and begins to thicken. An electric mixer will make the beating easier.

I have made this fudge and the first time it turned out and tasted amazing; ever since I made it after that time it hasn't set. I don't know what I am doing wrong. Please help me to figure this out.
Thanks Georgia

Carnation says:
Hi Georgia, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge - the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat for about 10 min. The trick is to allow it to cool for a minute before you start beating

Could you please tell me how long the fudge will keep once made and how to store it. Thanks

Carnation says:
Hello Gail, this fudge is best stored in an airtight container, at room temperature, for up to 5 days.

I need to know what can be used instead of condensed milk since all I can find is sweetened condensed milk.

Carnation says:
Hello Laura, Carnation condensed milk is also referred to as sweetened condensed milk. They're the same thing, so no need to find a replacement! This can be used in all appropriate recipes.

Is it salted or unsalted butter?

Carnation says:
Hello Saffron, this favourite recipe works with either salted or unsalted butter, but we usually use unsalted for all our baking.

Can you dye this fudge recipe another color? Love this fudge but need it pink.

Carnation says:
Hello Sally, yes this fudge can be dyed a colour. For best results use caster sugar instead of demerara for a paler fudge base, then add a few drops of colour.

I've used whole milk and it's delicious. Melted butter and sugar first as someone previously advised to prevent graining-worked a treat. Added rum soaked raisens at the end of stage 2 and it's just fabulous.

Carnation says:
Hello Vicky, what a delicious treat to share! We are very happy to hear that we have another Carnation Ultimate Fudge fan!

Well I stirred for over 20 min. and then stirred it off the heat for around 7 min. End up with a fudge like spread. What did I do wrong

Carnation says:
Hello Sally, sorry to hear you are having trouble with your fudge. It is important to bring your mixture to a steady boil until it reaches soft boil stage or 118C.

This fudge is amazing! However, whenever I try to make it myself, I can't seem to get the fudge to 118degrees during simmering. It has a hard time even getting to 100, and when I leave it on the stove for too long it begins to burn. I'm not sure why this is happening, as my coworker has successfully made this fudge many times. I would love to be able to make it myself but I'm not sure where I'm going wrong.

Carnation says:
Hello Chelsea, this recipe is a big hit here in the Carnation kitchen. A good tip is to use a heavy based pan to ensure a consistent boil and make sure to keep stirring, this will stop the fudge from burning. If you are unsure that the fudge has hit 118C, try testing it for soft boil stage.

Hi made this and it turned out great, my friend asked me to make maple and pecan fudge how much maple syrup and when do I add it.
Please help

Carnation says:
Hi Julie, what a lovely combination! For maple flavoured fudge, try adding two tablespoons at the beginning of the process. Gently toast and chop 50g of pecan nuts and then add during the beating stage.

I made the chocolate fudge in the microwave. Perfect.
Is it possible to make this fudge in the microwave?

Carnation says:
Hello Carole, this Ultimate Fudge Recipe is a hob and saucepan recipe. The time spent making it is always worth it! The most important stage is the boiling and then the beating. It is important that the fudge is boiled long enough to reach 115 C, then beat it until cooled.

Does this recipe require whole milk?

Carnation says:
Hello Kelly, we have made this recipe with semi skimmed milk and the result is just as delicious.

how long do you leave the mix to set before eating? because i just made some but i don't want to cut it too early.

Carnation says:
Hello Natsu, the Ultimate Fudge mixture should be left until it is completely cooled before cutting. The wait will be worth it!

i made this and am waiting for it to cool but I'm sure that it will taste delish!

Hi could I use double cream instead of milk for a creamier fudge ?

Carnation says:
Hello Hellen, if you are after a creamier fudge then try mixing this one in a large mixer until it is almost set. This will give you a very smooth, melt in your finish without the extra calories.

Hi could someone please help me, I've tried 2 attempts at this fudge, first my thermometer broke and I ended up with a toffee, lovely but not what I was going for and the second attempt I followed video to the letter did the soft ball test instead and its come out crumbly! It tastes great but not the right texture it crumbles in your finger tips, please help would love to get this right, thanks.

Carnation says:
Hello Carrie, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge - the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after. The better you beat the mixture the smoother it will become!

I have made this and the tablet a few times now and always turns out lovely!

Hello, I am new to this site and want to make the ultimate fudge. Can I use the light condensed milk for this recipe?

Carnation says:
Hello Anne, the Carnation Condensed Milk can be replaced for the Carnation Light Condensed Milk in this recipe.

This is the easiest recipe iv tried..I also put in at step 4 orange essence....it was lovely...thanks carnation ....'sweetie'

Carnation says:
Hello Violet, baking can be so creative! We love to hear how each baker personlises their creations!

Love this, made as gifts. So easy to make too, the easiest I've found so far. I followed the tip from cat12 and it worked well.

Im been making this for ages. I always let the temperate go one degree over the soft ball stage and mix in what i wish to add .then mix it in and pour straight in to tins sprayed with non-stick spray and it starts to set straight away with out all the mixing. Works all the time

I made this,was a bit reluctant as I have had my own recipe for years,Iwas delighted at results and after a few hints on the comments board I tried a tea spoonful of coffee at whisking stage ...then walnuts...so I have a delicious coffee and walnut fudge...so easy...and will look forward to giving to friends...so glad I joined Carnation...thank you.

Very good recipe and great for fudge lovers

Just made a trial batch for Christmas using boozy brandy soaked dried fruit (aldi). Stirred in before beating stage. OMG YUM

AMAZING.........

I made this today and forgot the milk! Lol. Not complaining though as whatever it is is still delicious! Will make it again though soon and this time I will remember the milk! Lol

I swapped the 150ml of milk to 150ml of Bailey's. the kitchen smelled lovely and they went down really well with the street.

I've made this fudge several times and have used all kinds of sugar to make it, including caster, granulated, golden caster, Demerara and light brown sugar, I've always combined the sugars in various ways based on whatever I have in the house. The fudge always works and is always delicious. But I've had the most luck with 325g light brown sugar and 125g Demerara. I simmer it for 15 minutes for a firm fudge with a texture like thick wet sand. I add a pinch of sea salt after I turn the heat off before I start beating it. It makes the perfect fudge, the hint of salt makes you crave more and more, which may or may not be a good thing.

Fab

After stage 2 I added a couple of tablespoons of baileys....... now that was nice..... also added morrisons white chocolate and raspberry.....

I love this recipe - it works every time. I ring the changes by switching the demarara sugar for either lighter or darker varieties. One of my absolute favourites is to use molasses sugar - Mmmm, bonfire fudge!

I made this for my birthday party and it was gone in the first 2 hours and i had every one begging for more

I've just made this lovely fudge and it turned out amazing. The only thing instead of 10/15 minutes simmering I'd say 20/25 minutes. Very very sticky when pitting on baking tray you have to work very quickly. Would make this again for sure.

I just made this fudge lovely and smooth top class

Just made two batches of this fudge.The first i made peanut butter and the second batch was caramel topped with bits of marshmallow.It's all turned out amazing! Great recipe! =)

Delicious! I found that the times given in this recipe were a lot shorter than it took me. Using a thermometer it was way longer than 15 min to get anywhere near 118 deg, even then it didn't reach temp. The texture was perfect, not grainy at all. My dad calls it Russian Cream and said he hadn't had anything like it since he was a child, so it was a big hit in our house! Would recommend this recipe but don't assume the times given are always accurate!

I have just made this and it's so easy! And I really can't cook! I had no thermometer but the ball in water trick worked! I Had a little doubt but when reading comments I seen it was taking a little longer than recipe stated so kept going and looked like every step ! Just waiting for it to cool! Very happy so far! 😃

Just made this n waiting for it to set... It's defiantly worth investing in a mixer for step 3 ... I feel like i have an arm like Arnold and I have a blister lol... Can't wait to try some :)

I added peanut butter, absolutely delicious.

I've just made this can't wait to try it as I added a GOOD slug of baileys after step 2

MMMM I have just made this amazing recipe. I decided to make fudge, and had several recipes I had culled from various sources ..... All looked very daffy oops, faffy I meant, and expensive, double cream, etc etc. I remembered this site from ages ago, and so I registered and found this recipe. Wow ..... What a star . I followed the recipe EXACTLY. You have to. And it repaid me!!!! Mmmmmmmm will it keep till tomorrow I wonder ....... Hubbie has yet to taste it. Better hide it!! PS. I did sprinkle some sea salt over it when in tin......Thankyou

I made this last week and it was delicious! It did not last long at all. I was thinking of giving it to my friends and family as an extra treat along with their presents.. I was wondering how long is will last once made?

Lovely easy recipe..At stage two I added 50g each of crushed pecan nuts & sultanas, really delicious.

At stage two I added 50g of crushed Pecans & 50g of Sultanas result was perfection..an easy & delicious recipe.

very good making fudge

Love this fudge everyone has said how nice it tastes. Easy to make but I did have to use a thermometer and an electric wink at the end but it turned out really good.

OMG i am so happy i have been trying to make fudge for so long but never come out right but found this site and see this so thought one more try if it dont work i would give up but how easy it was and it come out 1st time will never try any thing else now will be staying with this one always thanks Carnation

This fudge is amazing!! I have a ceramic hob and find it easier to melt the butter sugar and milk first then add the condensed milk otherwise it tends to caramelise and I end up panicking trying to swap pans. I've made this so many times and always goes down well! My partner took some into work and now I keep getting pestered for more and more. Lovely easy recipe :D

I have just made this for my family and added orange zest and cinnamon, fudging lovely ;0)

I made it with the tinned caramel from Carnation. It worked so well and tasted amazing. I used a sugar thermometer it takes the panic out of the preparation. Next time I might add coffee to dissolve into at stage 2 as it's a lovely coffee colour already. This fudge is my new favorite confection. Thanks Carnation!

This looks great - I can't wait to try it! Can I check why it can be kept out of the fridge even though it contains milk? (I'm thinking of making for presents if all goes well!)
Thanks :)

I made this fudge and took some to work. I had nothing but compliments. So thank you xx

It didn't make it out of the kitchen... We ate it!!

Made this fudge very easy to make I will always use this recipe in future,do you think I could use black treacle to give it a treacle taste and what would I replace with it?

I found it really needed about 15-20 mins over an medium heat. I also used the hand mixer and it definately worked a treat. Well going by the feedback from the family and requests for other flavours

I make this fudge a lot and it always turns out well. The secret is patience and continual stirring which I find quite therapeutic! The soft ball stage is more like a streak of firmness but a spatula thermometer from Lakeland is ideal. I stirred in about a100 grams of broken white chocolate last week just before tipping the beaten mixture into the tin. To give a rippled effect.
I nearly always make it with granulated sugar as I think it gives it a slightly creamier texture. All in all a lovely recipe from Carnation!

I'm a 61 year old grandfather and I made this, much to the surprise and disbelief of the mothers at my granddaughter's school's Open Day. It disappeared so quickly I have been asked to make more. Great recipe and super easy, even for an old age amateur like me.

Such a lovely recipe to follow. Was looking for a recipe my lovely nan made when i was little but couldnt find - and that used Carnation Condensed Milk. Found this one and I made it first time over a week ago adding dark chocolate - and today I made the plain...Both are so delicious and easy to make. I use an electric whisk at the beating stage. Then pour into greased tin.

Just made this today and it was so easy! Followed the video rather than the step by step instructions and it worked perfectly. Took longer than the time stated but I didn't mind and i added some vanilla essence at the end. I also used a silicone spatula as I found this better for scraping round the pan while cooking. It's setting just now, can't wait to try it!

I find it easier to use an electric food mixer for the 'beating' stage. You can get on with the washing up while it's mixing and no more arm ache! Also keep stirring really thoroughly at the simmering stage as it burns in the pan very easily.

I use this as a base recipe for fudge and tablet. This fudge has been made with Oreo cookies, drizzled with milk choc and bits of cinder toffee and also made with bits of mini eggs - not all at once - although that would still be eaten in my house. Would it be possible to add fruit to the fudge? I was thinking apple and cinnamon....or is that a step too far in my experimenting??!

Carnation says:
Hi Deb, sounds like you some very delicious ideas! Cinnamon would work and be quite lovely. We would recommend adding fresh ingredients as they will release more liquid and change the texture. Also fresh ingredient s would give a you a shorter shelf life. That said dried apple pieces could be added.

Hi I was just wonder how long does it last as I'm having a party on Friday and thinking of making it today

Carnation says:
Hi Lolo we would suggest keeping the fudge in an airtight box in a cool dry place (no need to refrigerate!). It should keep fine for about 3 weeks. Though it never lasts that long in the Carnation Kitchen!

Tasty but crumbly but last time it was perfection. :-)

I made this today and it really does taste amazing - I had a little trouble making it thicken but after I re- boiled it and followed the steps again and it went like a dream . . . Thanks :)

Hi I'm gonna make fudge for the first time,I haven't got a thermonator will that be ok? Abit scared of making it!!

Carnation says:
Hi Michelle, fudge is a very delicious treat and far easier than it seems. there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

I didn't have any demerara sugar in the cupboard but it worked great with the caster sugar I had left over! Added honeycomb pieces after strep 2 which tasted great, first time making fudge and it was fab

I made a batch of chocolate fudge by adding two tblsps of cocoa powder to the ingredients and the fudge turned out to be superb .

I love this fudge and would like to make a chocolate orange one but using this recipe how much chocolate should I use and do I use orange zest and juice and how much should I use or would orange flavouring be better and again how much please thanks

I'd like to put this fudge into a glass or fancy cup as a gift and I'd therefore like it to be a touch looser in texture. How do I achieve this - is it as simple as adding more milk? And if so, how much, would you think? Thanks

What should i do when it starts to caramelize during step 2 when i am boiling it and it does not start to form fudge when i do the ice cold water check!??!!

Carnation says:
Hi Thea, if at any stage you find dark pieces coming up from the bottom then remove from the heat and transfer into a new pan. Return to the heat and continue boiling until 116C.

I love the taste of RootBeer so I was wondering could i add this to fudge?
if I used Zatarain's RootBeer extract, how much should I use and at what point should I add it..?
All the best.

Carnation says:
Hi Ryan, that's not a flavour we've tried. We recommend adding 50 ml with the other ingredients in the Step 1. If you use white sugar the flavour will be more recognisable.

Be very careful in making this. Two things the recipe failed to mention:
- The mixture will increase as it cooks so use a big pot to avoid spilling over.
- If you don't stir constantly and use full fat milk, it will likely curdle. It's still edible but may not taste quite as good.

Other than that, it seems to have worked so far, I'm just waiting for it to set so I can see what damage the milk might have done.

Made this fudge tonight just in time for Valentine's Day tomorrow. It turned out better than I hoped and my process looked JUST like the pictures. My boyfriend is gonna have a sugar overdose. Thanks a lot!!! :-D

We made this at Christmas but it took a very long time to go thick. We also did it again this time using a electric mixer hope fully going to be quicker.

made this today delicious but more like tablet to taste than fudge. only thing I didn't use was butter I used utterly butterly...any advice on the texture

Carnation says:
Hi Laura, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

I used this recipe as a base for peanut butter fudge, I just added in a giant tablespoon of crunchy peanut butter before pouring it in to the tray. Also, mine seems to take longer than the time stated (I don't have a thermometer) and I have a ceramic hob. Still a great recipe :-)

OH MY! Made this for the first time today. Who knew making fudge was so easy! It turned out amazingly. Made it plain, and used white sugar (had demerara but was expecting the first lot to come out wrong, so used white as a test batch!) Will be making rum and raisin with demerara when this lot gets eaten... at this rate it'll be tomorrow!
I think people over beat using electric beaters and that's why theirs go wrong. I used my good ol' boyfriends muscle!

My fudge is very funny, i have beat it for 20mins and it is not thickening at all! What can i do to rescue it?

Carnation says:
Hi R, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

What's demerara sugar?

Carnation says:
Hi Wafa, Demerara is a brown sugar found in the sugar aisle in most stores.

I have made this fudge before and it was a little grainy but i after reading some comments i think this was because i started beating it too soon. I want to make peanut butter fudge, i read someone else had tried and it turned oily, if i were to replace all the butter in the recipe for peanut butter, do you think this would work?

Carnation says:
Hi Charlotte, if the peanut butter is cooked it will release its oils. The best way of doing this is to add 2 tbsp. during the beating process once its cooled slightly.

have you at carnation got a good recipe for toffee plz

Carnation says:
Hi Sharon, if you cook the ultimate fudge recipe for longer until the mixture is at least 132C or reaches what we call 'soft crack' stage then pour into a dish without beating you will get a delicious toffee. Just be careful because it becomes easier for the mixture to catch and burn the longer you cook it for.

Absolutely gorgeous fudge anda great present to give for xmas put in little chunks of milk chocolate or cherry, s for an extra sweet tooth

Made this for first time today used my wok turned out well will experiment more next time adding bits to it 😊

the butter that i use is it unsulted or sulted

Carnation says:
Hi, Margaret we recommend unsalted but both will work!

shirley 22 dec 2013
can you make fudge with the caramel one,

Carnation says:
Hi Shirl's, Carnation Caramel makes a delicious fudge, its just as creamy but a liitle richer. Substitute the Carnation Caramel for the Carnation Condensed milk and white caster sugar for demerera. Otherwise the other ingredients and instructions remain as they are. Enjoy!

I have been making this for everyone over the past couple of weeks...I'm even starting to get requests for it...just follow the instructions to the letter and it will turn out perfectly every time

As a Brit living in USA, my thermometer has just died. The replacements, both reputable brands, don't reach 212F when I put them in boiling water. If they only register 208F rather than 212, should I then use 234F for soft ball stage rather than 238F. Cold water test did work but as a chef I am so used to a thermometer. for those who have problems getting sugar to melt, I melt butter with milk and then add sugar and heat very gently until sugar is totally melted and only then add condensed milk and cook. Also when I leave cooked fudge to cool for 10-20 minutes, I only had to beat it with an electric mixer for about 1 minute. I so missed good English fudge, American is over sweet and hard like tablet. thanks, everyone is very happy this week.

I made this n it was easy to do though I got arm ache! Ha. I added baileys instead of milk n it was yummy :)

Carnation says:
Hi Claire, Arm ache is one of the risks of making delicious fudge. You could try finding some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

Hello, your recipe calls for condensed milk but I'm only able to find evaporated milk. Will this work?
Thank you,
Mo

Carnation says:
Hi Mo, evaporated milk is simply a more concentrated milk however condensed milk is concentrated with a high percentage of sugar added. Evaporated milk will not work as a substitute in this recipe.

Fab recipe and so easy. I had none of this problems some people encountered. Didn't need a sugar thermometer and don't have the best hob in the world, but it still worked a treat. Making more fore sure.

I've followed this recipe with success... wondered if you could make it with low fat carnation milk? (not that I want it to be low fat, I just happen to have low fat in the cupboard and need to use it up!)

Carnation says:
Hi Sarah, Yes Carnation Light Condensed Milk can be used in this recipe.

Hi all

Made this fudge today and turned out great, I added coarsely ground sea salt to my fudge at the beating stage and it totally transforms the flavour. Definitely a favourite of mine from now on.

Can I use soft brown sugar instead of Demerara ??

Carnation says:
Hi Selah, soft brown sugar will give you a darker fudge with a stronger toffee flavour but you will still get a good result.

Hello! I am excited to try out this recipe out - I wanted to make a chocolate candy cane flavour. I will be adding the candy cane bits at the end - what I am unsure of is how much cocoa powder to add at step one to achieve a nice rich chocolate flavour too?
Thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Amy, 2 tablespoons of cocoa powder will give you a good rich chocolatey fudge flavour but you can adjust this as to your preference!

If I was adding white chocolate at the how much would you recommend?

Carnation says:
Hi GMAC, if you are making white chocolate fudge why not try the easy chocolate fudge recipe and subsitute the white chocolate for dark in equal quantity.

The fudge turned out really well but I want to give it as presents in a little bag. How can I stop the pieces sticking together?
Thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Meg, make sure you keep the fudge in airtight containers. You can dust the fudge with either sieved icing sugar or cocoa powder to stop it from sticking but this can also effect the flavour.

Is there a way to reduce the sugar? Delicious but very very sweet!!! Fudge setting as I type... Don't think any will end up as Christmas gifts!!!

Carnation says:
Hi Krissy, the sugar is crucial to the setting of the fudge. It never lasts long in the Carnation kitchen either.

Any ideas as to how to make this a Christmas fudge for gifts?

Carnation says:
Hi Libby, you could either add some christmas ingredients such as cranberries or nuts or if you make it with white sugar instead of demerera you could colour half red and half green. Then wrap them up in little bags and tie with pretty ribbon. They make a lovely gift.

how long will the fudge keep for im making it in a food hamper for xmas

Carnation says:
Hi lou1 the fudge will last for up to 3 weeks in an airtight container.

Hi I attempted this for the first time and although it was very tasty it was hard Please tell me what I am doing wrong !

Carnation says:
Hi Toughangel73, the fudge needs to cook to 116C or soft ball stage before beating. If you cook it for longer it will get harder.

i love fuge

So I made this recipe and I absolutely love it! it came out perfectly smooth and soft! Never been able to make fudge that sets so perfectly! Definitely a tip to anyone keep it out of the fridge after it sets and store it in a airtight container, it stays so soft!
Anyway I have a question, now I want to make a bunch of flavors for Christmas but the recipe isn't really clear how to do this. I assume with flavorings I can just add them to the fudge as I am beating it. But as far as adding White chocolate or Peanut butter chips, how do I do that without ruining the fudge? Any help would be appreciated! Thank you!

Carnation says:
Hi Jessica, sounds like you've really mastered the Ultimate Fudge. Adding the flavourings at the beating stage is the right choice. If you want to make white chocolate fudge why not try the easy chocolate fudge recipe and substitute the dark chocolate for white. As far as peanut butter goes you can add a tablespoon at the beating stage and your fudge will still set. Or alternatively try adding whole unsalted peanuts.

Hi could you make this with Light Condensed Milk ?

Carnation says:
Hi Jet, this recipe works fine with the light version!

Could I use caramel instead of plain?

Carnation says:
Hi Finn, Carnation Caramel makes a delish fudge, its just as creamy but a liitle richer. Substitute the Carnation Caramel for the Carnation Condensed milk and white caster sugar for demerera. Otherwise the other ingredients and instructions remain as they are. Enjoy!

Hi - I have made this fudge, but every time I did the cold water test, it did not go into a soft ball. So I could not get it to set properly.

Carnation says:
Hi Lynka, if you boil the ingredients for long enough it will start to thicken and then will reach soft ball stage. It does take about 10 - 15minutes of boiling but the result is worth the wait!

Thinking of making this for Christmas present , how long will it keep for ?

Carnation says:
Hi springer1, the ultimate fudge recipes keeps for about 3 weeks if kept in an airtight container

I found a recipe for white choc fudge but not actually heating it ... But it's not set :/ any recommendations on how to make proper white choc
Fudge?

Carnation says:
Hi Ruthy, we have a very Easy Chocolate Fudge recipe on the Carnation Website. Remove white for dark chocolate in equal measure for best results.

I know that you said this keeps for a couple of weeks in an airtight box however I'd like to know if it's ok to freeze. I'd like to make this now for Xmas pressies, freeze and give to people nearer the time. I won't have any time spare to make 2 weeks before Xmas. Hope you can advise. Joyce

Carnation says:
HI Joyce, this recipe is not appropriate for freezing. The high sugar content means that it will absorb water and become very sticky. It will last for at least 3 weeks in an airtight container so hopefully this will help over busy periods.

Hi, i tried to make this fudge recipe, but somewhere i must have gone wrong. When I was at the boiling stage, i suddenly saw en smelled burnt suger popping up in a few places. I hadn't stopped stirring or anything so this surprised me. How did this happen? Also I had put the heat higher to bring it to a boil, maybe that is also what made my fudge more brown? Do you have to keep the temparature low and just wait a long while? Also what i didn't really get was the simmering. Are you supposed to bring the temperature up to 116 and then take the pan immediately off the heat? or is it meant that you should keep it at the heat for 10-15 minutes? I kept it there for a bit but it didn't seem right. When i was finally done and tried stirring it looked fine, but when putting it in the prepared tin it seemed not fluid enough and already grainy. Even though i stopped stirring when the gloss became matte. What did i do wrong?

Carnation says:
Hi Wendy, many home bakers find fudge tricky. There's a bit science around the cooking! When the sugar initially starts to boil it will be at about the temperature of boiling water 100C but as water evaporates off the boiling temperature goes up! This is why we boil it for 10 to 15 minutes. As the temperature goes up the sugar changes and as a result when it cools the crystals form and we get the wonderful fudge that everyone loves. So to answer the question: Bring the ingredients to the boil at a medium heat and boil until it reaches 116C then remove from the heat. Beat until it is getting thick and then press into a tin.

Hi it's my first time ever making fudge and it's not thickening I added cocoa powder and powdered sugar but it's just like hot chocolate what should I do

Carnation says:
Hi X, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enought to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

Can I use the caramel version of the condensed milk to make this fudge

Carnation says:
Hi Flower. The Carnation Caramel is perfect for banoffee and other treats. It is already a cooked form of Carnation Condensed milk and so is not suitable for the fudge recipe.

Hello, I will be making this on the weekend, have you got any tips to get the perfect fudge?

Carnation says:
Hi Glenda, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enought to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

Hmmm my mixture went dark very fast and started to get very thick and burnt... So I whisked it and now have fudge toffee.... Didn't realise you could over boil it? Is it better to heat very slowly?

Carnation says:
Hi Andrea, you can over cook fudge but luckily toffee is quite delicious too. We cook the fudge on a medium to high heat but what is very important is that you stir constantly to stop it from sticking. Make sure you get right inTO the corners!

I made this for the first time today. It tastes great but when I put it into the prepared tin it looked all powdery and not smooth as I expected it to look, did I over beat it?

Carnation says:
Hi Tracey, it does sound that beating could have been the problem. It could also be that the mixture cooked a bit too long. There are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. As it starts to thicken visibly pour it into the tray.

Ahhhh fudge nightmare twice iv tried this and it just won't set !

Carnation says:
Hi Icelolly08, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

What type of milk do I need for this recipe please?

Carnation says:
Hi Bee, we use semi skimmed but whole or skimmed will work just as well

Can you use light muscovado sugar instead of Demerara sugar in this recipe?

Carnation says:
Hi Melanie, yes light muscavado will work in this recipe although you will notice a difference in colour and flavour. It will be darker and have a stronger caramel flavour.

hi i have made this fudge turned out perfect but i want to make mint fudge but not sure how much peppermint extract i should use

Carnation says:
Hi Janerum, mint fudge is delicious! Just a couple of drops of peppermint makes delicious minty treats.

How could you adapt the recipe to make baileys fudge?

Carnation says:
Hi CheekyMonkey, If you want to add Bailey's you could replace the milk in the recipe. Take out 50ml milk and replace with 50ml of Baileys.

Great Idea Nadia I will try that next time

HI, i would like to make edible christmas hampers for the family, and do as much as possible in advance - hoe long would these last please?

Carnation says:
Hi Kay, Ultimate fudge is a great gift idea! Once made it will keep in airtight containers or wrapping for about 3 weeks.

Is it possible to flavour this fudge say with coconut or fresh berries. If so do I need to adjust ingredient to suit additional moisture of berries or dryness of coconut pls

Carnation says:
Hi Alicat,Add 100g of coconut at the beating stage works beautifully. Fresh berries on the other hand we've not tried. The concern would be the water in the berries would change the setting of the fudge. Dried berries such as blueberries or strawberries works very well when added at the beating stage.

I beat mine in a Kenwood mixer and after 4 mins it had almost set. What did I do wrong?

Carnation says:
Hi Meg, it may be that the fudge had cooked for a little longer than necessary. Fudge will always set quicker if you beat it with an electric beater because it cools quicker. It will also be smoother and creamier! Next time cook it until it has just reached the soft ball stage at 116C then tip it into the mixer and the result will be silky smooth.

I can't use the "print these step-by-step instructions" please advise?

Made this fudge for the first time today. Turned out perfect! Lovely recipe. Cannot wait to take into work so everybody can have a munch.

It's a great recipe but only works every other time but if it doesn't work I find blending it seems to help. I also started a mini business and sell it at events such as churches and fairs. Great recipe.

When it comes to adding choc at step 2 how much do you add?
White and milk? I have seen other recipes for white choc fudge and milk choc fudge but I like this recipe and actually manage to make it.

Carnation says:
Hi Gail, the best time to add the chocolate is at the end of the 'beating'. The fudge is still warm so the chocolate will melt. Add up to 100g chocolate to the recipe depending on how chocolatey you like it and it will flavour it beautifully .

Hi! Can you put Malteasers or/and Smarties? I made this countless times and it is a treasure with family and friends alike.Thanks.

Carnation says:
Hi Marissa, it's a favourite in the Carnation kitchen and never lasts long! We add all sorts of things to them. Just wait till you've finished the beating and then add your chocolates, fruits or nuts etc.

I made this it set fine it tastes fine but it crystalised what did I do wrong?

Carnation says:
Hi Marian. The secret to perfectly smooth fudge is to let it cool ever so slightly before beating. A couple of minutes of cooling time should do it. Then beat till it just starts to crystalise and pour into a baking tray.

Just made this and it is setting nicely in the fridge. I used an electric hand whisk to beat for the final stage and found it only took 3 minutes before it started to get quite thick. Now I have a recipe that works I can begin to think of other flavours!

Have just attempted to make this with the children.....'epic fail' in their language! It wouldn't reach 116 degrees, despite using a large pan on a wide hob , then burned badly and has been tipped down the sink. An expensive mistake.

Carnation says:
Hi Nicki, sorry to hear that you had a fudge nightmare. It is very important to keep the fudge on an even heat and to stir constantly. It is a very delicious and rewarding recipe once you get the knack!

I made this fudge firstly as the recipe stated, but it took a while to set. On my second attempt, I left out 10ml of milk and added 10ml of green food colouring (Liquid colouring). The fudge I made came out looking like slime!! it was perfect for a planned Halloween party. One word of advice...use an electric whisk or you'll end up with arms like Popeye!!!

How long do I have to let it set until I can cut it

Carnation says:
Hi Sarah, we recommend leaving the fudge to set for about 30minutes or until cool then it is easy to turn out and cut.

Could you use a different type of sugar such as caster sugar to achieve a whiter colour? I want to colour the fudge for Christmas but have a feeling it will go a bit of a dodgy colour.

Carnation says:
Hi Chanel, you can use caster sugar and you'll get a lighter colour you'll still need to be careful which colours you choose as you are not starting with a white base.

I also had difficulty in reaching the temp. mentioned and it took 45 mins for the fudge to start to thicken by hand . The end result was , I am told yummylicious , so the effort was worth it.

Hi, I'd really like to make a chocolate orange fudge, maybe an adult version with orange liquor. When would I add the chocolate and the liquor and would I have to adjust any of the other ingredients? I'm also not entirely sure how much of each to use. Any suggestions gratefully received. Thanks.

Carnation says:
Hi Emma, what a lovely idea and very trendy! Why not try the carnation easy chocolate fudge recipe and add the zest of an orange in with all the ingredients before you begin melting. If you'd like it a bit boozy you could add 50ml liqour once all the ingredients are melted.

Hi I have just made my first batch of fudge and its like toffee were did I go wrong. (it looks and tastes ok)

Carnation says:
Hi Kay, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The tablet mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

Hello, is it okay to put the fudge in the fridge to help it set?

Carnation says:
Hi Ryan, we would suggest keeping the fudge in an airtight box in a cool dry place (no need to refrigerate!). As long as you've cooked the fudge to 118C (soft ball stage) and then beaten it according to the recipe the fudge will set. Enjoy

I've made this recipie many times and each time it's a success. I like it with a thin layer of dark chocolate over the top.

Can I freeze this fudge?

Carnation says:
Hi Teresa, rather than freezing fudge we would keeping it in an airtight box in a cool dry place. It should keep fine for about 3 weeks. Though it never lasts that long in the Carnation Kitchen!

I have made this several times, it's very popular! I use a stand mixer to do the beating and it works out perfectly every time.

This recipe is so wrong...
1. you cannot simmer anything to 116 degrees, i had it on rapid boil for 30 mins and only got it to 110.
2. i had my electric mixer on for 20mins to try and get it to a paste and failed....DO NOT add chocolate as it just melts..
3. 10x10 tin is far too large and you get a thin layer, i used a 8x8 tin, but its been in there for 5 days and still not set...ho hum

Carnation says:
Hi Jayne, sounds like you had a fudge nightmare! There are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get to 116 to set. We boil the fudge in a large saucepan on a wide hob to get even heat. Once its reached soft boil stage the beating will give it a soft texture and the result is luxurious fudge.

I didn't have enough Demerara sugar so made the quality up with soft brown and it worked well. Also I made a second lot by adding raisins soaked for a very short time in a little rum.

I really want to make a peppermint fudge (no chocolate). Would adding peppermint extract achieve this and would green food colouring work well with these ingredients? As in, the mixture looks quite brown and I don't want it to look awful if I add green colouring.

Carnation says:
Hi Carol, adding peppermint extract will give you a lovely minty fudge. Just a couple of drops will do the trick as the extract is usually very strong. You're right in being careful of colour you are starting from a browny base and this will effect the final result.

I have discovered 2 X 405g tins expirary date 05-2006 in the back of my cupboard. Can I still use them?
Also, in the depths of my memory - what was the recipe for boiling said tins for a long time?

Carnation says:
Hi Patricia, our products are carefully tested over their product life to ensure the safety of consumers and are dated accordingly, so we wouldn't recommend using those tins! Have you tried our Carnation caramel? It takes all the fuss out of boiling tins!

I wanted to make this for my mums birthday as fudge is her favorite. I followed the recipe as instructed then put it in a tin to set in the fridge, but three days later it didn't set, so my mum has now got no birthday present. I'm upset and my grandma's wasted money on the ingredients. I've made fudge before but never with condensed milk. What shall I do?

Carnation says:
Hi Sheila, we're sorry you're disappointed with your fudge. There are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge- the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enought to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after. The fudge is best setting in a cool dry place.

Great recipe,
Could you please give me some idea of how much rum and raisins I would need to add to the recipe and if I need to reduce the amount of milk. Thank you.

Carnation says:
Hi Elisabeth, try soaking 115g raisins in 2-3tbsp rum while you make the fudge, then stir in just towards the end of the beating stage, but while it's still soft. No need to adjust the milk

Hi ya I am looking to do a clotted cream fudge can I do this with this recipe if so how much would you recommend to use please? Thank you

Carnation says:
Hi Ady, what a deliciously decadent idea. We've not tried it as the Ultimate fudge is much loved in the Carnation Kitchen just as it is. We'll test this and get back to you.

Hi made some fudge today .but it came out very dry and crumbly what went wrong. Help please

Carnation says:
Hi Lesley sounds like the fudge could have been beaten too long, which can cause it to go grainy and crumble. Our trick is to let it cool a little first and then beat it until it becomes thick.

Hi again! I have mastered the fudge and I make it weekly. I'm experimenting, and I'm thinking if I can use food colouring inside.
(P.S do not use stork because it makes the fudge crumbly)

Carnation says:
Hi Marissa,colouring can make wonderful seasonal goodies for Christmas and special events.

My neighbour is very ill at the moment & she can't get enough of this fudge 4times in 2 weeks I've made it for her it's yummy

Carnation says:
Hi Sue, what a wonderful treat to brighten someone's day!

I have made fudge several times with no problem, but the last two times the texture is not completely smooth and looks rather grainy. Not sure why this is happening.

Carnation says:
Hi Linda, fudge can be temperamental sometimes! The secret is to let the mixture cool for a minute before you beat it. Transfer it into a bowl and mix with a wooden spoon.

I've done this one but its turned out really hard. I don't have a sugar thermometer so just kept it boiling. To get the soft fudge do I need to get a thermometer and how do I get the soft fudge

Carnation says:
Hi Tony, a thermometer does make it easier but a secret that we were taught if you don’t have a thermometer is to pour a small amount of the hot fudge into a bowl of cold water. If it is ready you will be able to handle it and it won't melt into the water. This is soft ball stage.

I'm not exactly sure what's happening (or even complaining) but when I make this fudge recipe it all goes perfect until I stir in flavorings (peanut butter, chocolate morsels, etc). The fudge become crumbly but still sets in the allotted time. When it's cut it closely resembles a scottish tablet. The fudge is still very delicious but it's strange that it spontaneously turns into a scottish tablet. Any thoughts or tips to correct this?

Carnation says:
Hi Miranda, those flavours sound great! I would suggest that the oils from the peanut butter change the texture, but it still sounds delicious. If you want chocolate fudge try adding cocoa powder to the ingredients at step 1 and then follow recipe as on the website.

This is a great recipe. I failed on my first attempt, didn't read the instructions carefully enough. Second attempt it was perfect, and my friends & neighbours love it. Thanks for sharing, will be making again!

I tried this but the demerara sugar just wouldn't dissolve. I was on step one for 25 minutes, but it was still there. Should i try a different type of sugar? Or do i need to have more patience?

Carnation says:
Hi Ashley, fudge does take patience but is well worth the wait. Stiring constantly should dissolve the sugar.

Once made, does it need to be refrigerated all the time? I've made it before but I'm planning on making it this week for the kids' teachers - will it be ok?

Carnation says:
Hi Sian we would suggest keeping the fudge in an airtight box in a cool dry place (no need to refrigerate!). It should keep fine for about 3 weeks. Though it never lasts that long in the Carnation Kitchen!

Just made this for the first time. Was a massive success. Might have to hide it from the boys or it will be eaten before the end of the night :D

hello wonder if ou could help me.i use you recipe for the fudge all the time and it's great.Would clotted cream work with in the fudge recipe??

Carnation says:
Hi Chantelle, what a deliciously decadent idea. We've not tried it as the Ultimate fudge is much loved in the Carnation Kitchen just as it is, but if you do try let us know how it goes!

Hello,
Your ultimate fudge: what would be the 'shelf life' of it, please, when stored in a cool, cupboard as opposed to fridge or freezer?

Many thanks

Debbie

Carnation says:
Hi Debbie we would suggest keeping the fudge in an airtight box in a cool dry place (no need to refrigerate!). It should keep fine for about 3 weeks. Though it never lasts that long in the Carnation Kitchen!

Can I use brown sugar or unrefined sugar

Carnation says:
Hi Alex you can use other sugars although bear in mind it will change the colour and flavour.

This is the recipe that I use for home-made gifts every Christmas. I get people giving me hints that they are looking forward to it from October onwards!

Just made this with my children and added rolos while setting! Mmmm.

I tried to make this 'ultimate fudge' but failed - I followed the recipe - to the letter - until step 3 when you are to beat it for about 10 mins - I gave up after an hour - it was still the same consistency as when I removed the pan from the heat. I've put it into the tray to see if it sets on its own.

Carnation says:
Hi Roy, the heating part of making fudge is very important. The mixture needs to get hot enought to set (about 116C). Then remove from the heat and allow to cool for a minute before beating.

I tried making this yesterday followed instructions but it would not set so I put it in the fridge and is has turned to toffee any advice?

Carnation says:
Hi Stephen, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge the heating and the beating! The fudge mixture needs to get hot enought to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat for about 10 min. The trick is to allow it to cool for a minute before you start beating

Just made this using dark brown soft sugar. Went well, although it went very thick so that I had trouble smoothing it into the tin. Tastes lovely though.

Carnation says:
Good to know Gail! Thanks for the tip!

Hi, how long life does the fudge have? Obviously if it is not all eaten ar once!! How long is it safe to keep for? Thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Amanda, we would suggest keeping the fudge in an airtight box in a cool dry place (no need to refrigerate!). It should keep fine for about 3 weeks. Though it never lasts that long in the Carnation Kitchen!

ive made this for fathers day he loves fudge my first time its so lovley make your own you will be suprized so will your dad xx

Carnation says:
What a lovely treat for father's day Nelly!

Hello great recipe , but can I use granulated sugar ? It is so hard to find Demerara sugar or light brown sugar over here.

Carnation says:
Hi Alex, it won't have the same flavour or colour but it should work ok. We haven't tested it so would love to know how you get on!

made this fudge recently and it was delicious, my first attempt and got great comments, everyone enjoyed it

Well I made the recipe 2 days ago, and there were a few mistakes I made, as no one touched my toffee mixture sitting in the fridge I decided to bite the bullet and put it back into the pot to reheat, low and behold it came back to life and now looks exactly like the picture, double thumbs up and the family especially my husband is "Happy" I must add this was my first attempt so my arms got a good workout!!!

Carnation says:
Nice work Milly! Well done for persisting - once you've mastered this recipe you'll become a very popular lady!

I don't seem very lucky in getting my fudge to set! First time I tried making this my fudge came out the right colour looked and smelled perfect but would not set. The second time I thought I would be brave and added currants, it turned a deliciously dark colour but again, would not set and has come out incredibly grainy! I'm pretty sure the grainy-ness is down to over-beating. But as for not setting am I missing something? the fudge forms a lovely soft ball of fudge in the water but still.. remains half set half unset.

Carnation says:
Hi Holli sounds to us like it might not be getting hot enough - do you have a food safe themometer that you can check the temperature before beating? And yes the more you beat the more grainy it becomes. Let the mixture cool a little first then beat it until it becomes thick, take a small piece and chill it down to see what the texture is like then you know its perfect!

Hi there, I have tried making fudge a few times now and it never seems to work! Have followed this recipe step by step but it never sets properly, tastes great, but when taking out the tin isn't set and it quite sloppy almost...what am I doing wrong?!

Carnation says:
Hi Alice, there are 2 very important stages to get right when making fudge or tablet- the heating and the beating! The tablet mixture needs to get hot enough to set (about 116C) and then you need to beat it until it starts to go grainy and very thick. If your arm gets tired get some hired muscle! Or tip the mixture into a bowl and beat with an electric hand mixer - soak the beaters in boiling water after.

Would the temperature be different at the coast? If you think about boiling temperatures at higher altitudes....

Carnation says:
Hi Philippa, hmm we're not experts in temperature differences but we don't think the difference if any would be that dramatic... So stick with our recommendation and see how you get on!

Just made this fab fudge although I didn't have a tin of condensed milk I had the 450g squeezy bottle. I was expecting to be able to get 397g out of it but struggled to get 350 and I even cut open the bottle and scraped it out. It was a new sealed bottle. Can you please let me know if the 397g tin has 397g of milk in it or its the weight of the tin + milk? what is the exact quantity of condensed milk needed? I added an extra 50ml of milk to the pan, hoping that it would work but just take a little longer to cook - which is what happened. It did turn out brill. The video and pics were very helpful.
Thanks

Hiya, Can you double or triple this recipe when you have a bid family?Someone told me you can't.

Many thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Hilde, the mixture can be a bit more difficult to control in bigger quantities. But if you have a really good heavy based very large saucepan and a large stove you can keep the heat even. Keep on stirring and make sure you don't rush the stages. Our advice is only to double the mixture not treble. Don't forget the mixture will rise up in the pan and you don't want hot fudge all over your stove!

I just made this! I have never made fudge before. This recipe was easy to follow, and the fudge is scrumptious. I have a very happy fudge fuelled family today :-)

Carnation says:
Hi D! Sounds like you are 'Masters' of fudge making! Well done!

Can I use light brown sugar in this recipe

Carnation says:
Hi Joanne, yes we think this should be fine - though we haven't tested it ourselves - let us know how you get on!

Hi can I use an electric whisk ?

Carnation says:
Hi Barbara, let it cool a little first and then very carefully tip the mixture into a bowl to beat. Then once its finished beating, place into the tin and give the fudge a good whack on the surface to remove any air pockets or bubbles. Soak the bowl and beaters in hot water to remove any sticky fudge!

can i have some advice please. The beating of the fudge - could it be done in a Kenwood mixer? I cant beat due to shoulder probs

Carnation says:
Hi Alison yes you can - let it cool a little first and then very carefully tip the mixture into the bowl to beat. Then once its finished beating, place into the tin and give the fudge a good whack on the surface to remove any air pockets or bubbles. Soak the bowl and beaters in hot water to remove any sticky fudge!

This was my 1st time of making fudge & although it took a lot longer than 25 min, it turned out lovely, I cut it into tiny pieces & it tasted perfect, :-)

Can you make this fudge using your caramel flavoured condensed milk.

Carnation says:
Hi Susan, we don't advise using our Caramel as it tends to turn the fudge too dark and toffee tasting - but it depends if you like it that way!

I have attempted this 3times using a sugar thermometer and the liquid doesn't get hot enough, but no matter how little I stir it always ends up really hard a d grainy like Scottish tablet

Carnation says:
Hi Debbie, perhaps if you try instead to drop a little of the mixture when its been boiling for about 10 minutes into a jug of very cold water - if it forms a soft ball in your fingers it should be ready to beat. Let it cool a little before you start beating it then beat until thickened.

I have made 3 batches in as many days trying to perfect my fudge. Batch 1 - a little gritty, batch 2 - a little crumbly so batch 3 (having purchased a thermometer and a new pan) a little crumbly again. The family all think its lovely but I felt a little disappointed. Perhaps I am a little too critical and the softer more moist type fudge is a little more mass produced? I would love some feedback.

Carnation says:
Hi Paula, sounds like the final beating stage you could reduce down a bit - this makes the fudge crumbly or grainy the longer you beat it. You must have very toned arms by now! Hope that helps!

made this recipe the other day! I absolutley love it. Instead I made it with soft brown sugar which gave it a lovely treacle taste.

Carnation says:
Sounds Yummy Millie!

Hi me again, Some how my fudge mixture, the sugar doesn't dissolve properly and when it does it's crystallising and grainy. Where am I going wrong this time? Your help would be most appreciated. Thank you

Carnation says:
Hi Ady, what sort of pan are you using? The best ones for fudge are heavy based non stick saucepans with a wide rim - this allows for even heating through the process. Do the first stage gently and keep stirring - if you see any sugar crystals make sure they're incorporated and melted down before moving on... best of luck with the next batch!

Just had an experimental bash at this recipe using what I already had in the kitchen. I had to substitute some of the butter with Flora Cuisine and only had white sugar. The end result is, it's a pale creamy colour and a slightly gooey texture. But I am storing it in the fridge and it tastes awesome and melts in the mouth!

Mmm, fridge fudge! I'm happy! ;)

Carnation says:
Brilliant Sarah, sounds like you mastered it completely!

Love this fabulous fudge recipe, if you add oats after step 2 and bake at 160c for 20 mins you get the best flapjacks in the world!

Carnation says:
Wow Suzy, what a fab idea!

Did it last night, but it went rock hard. I checked the temperature and it was 118C. I used ordinary sugar, could it be the reason?

Carnation says:
Hi Louloutte, yes the sugar could have played a part in the texture being too hard and also it may have been beaten for too long?

I made this last night for a friends birthday present. I only wanted a small amount so I halved the quantities. It didnt want to thicken and I lost a little patience so when it had been in the fridge for two hours and was not set and just looked like caramel I panicked. I returned the whole lot on to the heat again and melted it down again, brought it back up to the boil then beat. It worked. It is the best sweet I have ever made and the lesson I learnt; FOLLOW THE INSTRUCTIONS.

Carnation says:
Hi Fiona! Well done you for rescuing the fudge - glad you loved it! :-)

i made tablet but it went too hard

Carnation says:
Hi Mary, it might have got a little too hot or perhaps it needed a little less beating - did you use a sugar thermometer? It only needs to be beaten until it thickens. It can be tricky first time but once you've mastered it you'll be a very popular lady!

I have made this several times, added white chocolate to todays batch. I am trying different flavours as my daughter wants me to make it for her wedding, so whisky is next on the list. It has been easy and delicious, thank you.

Carnation says:
Hi Maggie, what a lovely idea! Many congratulations on your daughters upcoming wedding! Glad you love the recipe :)

Hi I made fudge I followed your recipe but its really gritty

Carnation says:
Hi Michelle, it might be because either the sugar hadn't completely melted in the first stage -or it needed less beating at the end. Have another go we promise it will be worth it!

I made this today and the result was amazing!!! I used dark sugar and that gave it a more treacle taste! Could you used light condensed milk? I used condensed but I'm wondering wether I could use light?

Carnation says:
Hi Millie, yes good news you can use the light - both light and standard condensed are interchangeable on all recipes! Glad you loved the recipe! : )

ive tried it too but it it is very soft can i re-do it by reheating it now its cold?

Carnation says:
Hi George, you can re-heat it but it is likely to go much darker and get quite hard so melt it gently as before and then make sure you stir it constantly while it boils to prevent it catching - try just another couple of minutes boiling or check with a thermometer for the right temperature.

i made this with coconut cream last week was a hit with work, this week i made it with Baileys, both times turned out perfect, x

Carnation says:
Wow Ann, both ideas sound amazing! : )

Can you use your canned caramel to make this and use less sugar?
i have a tin spare and i've made a banoffee pie already.

Carnation says:
Hi Jo, no we think best not to use the caramel for the fudge as it will turn too dark when you caramelise it. Why not try our chocolate fudge cake or banoffee muffins with the caramel instead?

I don't have butter but want to make it tonight, can I use stork instead?

Carnation says:
Hi Leanne, we've not tested it with margarine but think it should work... Did you try it?

My advice to anyone who finds this fudge too sweet is to try adding a little flaked coconut (unsweetened) to the recipe. Not only is this a delicious combination, but also the coconut seems to neutralize some of the sweetness.

Carnation says:
Hi David, top tip - this sounds delicious! : )

I have just made the fudge although using a thermometer.I thought fudge might be nice in little bags for favours for my daughters wedding.
If I double or treble the recipe will the results still be as good.Trying to save time with smaller amounts

Carnation says:
Hi Viv, what a lovely idea! Yes you can increase the quantity - we suggest just doubling and make sure you have a really big pan and keep a very close eye on the mixture. Keep stirring the mixture and go through the stages carefully so it doesn't burn. Huge congratulations to your daughter and best wishes from Carnation! :)

Made this recipe twice. The first time it would not set properly, but still tasted great. The second time i watched the video and tested the fudge in iced water....it worked a treat. It is so good and knocks spots off shop bought fudge.

Carnation says:
Hi Michelle, we love it too! Can't beat homemade in our book!

made the fudge from this recipe and it was a hit,only thing i would say is to boil the mixture fore longer than the recipe says,other than that it tasted great,
ps have just made the tablet and its turned out brilliant

Carnation says:
Hi Brian, sounds like you're almost professional now! Will you try to adapt the recipe with other flavours now?

Hi I have tried this recipe a few times but recently I seem to be doing something wrong, my fudge keeps turning out really crumbly, why is this can you please help me? thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Ady, sounds like perhaps it might have got a little too hot or perhaps you're stronger than you think and have slightly over beaten it?

I made this yesterday and it turned out beautifully. The only thing was it was a tab too sweet for some people, would I be able to cut down the amount of sugar used and still get the same results? Thanks

Carnation says:
Hi Jessica, we can't guarantee the results with a reduction in sugar so wouldn't advise it. The sugar helps to set the fudge. Perhaps you could cut smaller cubes instead?

Brilliant, turned out perfectly!

I am doing a bake sale for Comic Relief, and I want to wrap the fudge to make it pretty, and, because it is at the school where I am, so there isnt any cotamination of any sort. However, the only way I can achieve this is by making the fudge a day before. When does the fudge expire?

Carnation says:
Hi Marissa, good news... The fudge will keep happily in an airtight box for about 3 weeks (if you can keep your hands off it for that long!). What a lovely idea! You can buy small sweet bags from supermarkets and cake accessory websites if you want to go really professional?!

hi, I've tried a few different fudge recipes and yes it takes patience and sticking to what your told to do is key because if you stray it will fail. I have had to soft, rock hard and have made most of the mistakes that I have read here. You can't do this without a thermometer - they are cheep so is worth investing in one if you like doing this sort of thing. Make sure you have an extra large pan as it trebles in volume - and keep stirring - keep the heat only to a simmer after bringing to the boil or it will burn and caramelize. WELL WORTH THE EFFORT - my boy and family love it and now is a xmas present family really look forward to. Just to add - THIS IS THE BEST TASTIEST FUDGE RECIPE I HAVE TRIED & WILL NOW KEEP TOO. HAVE TRIED COCONUT ICE & CHOC FUDGE CAKE - BRILLIANT. WORKING MY WAY THROUGH THE RECIPES ON THIS SITE AS THEY ARE ALL DELICIOUS......THANKS CARNATION FOR MAKING HAPPY FACES & TUMS

Carnation says:
Hi Clare, well what can we say...?! But you're welcome! So glad you love our recipes - your fudge advice is spot on! We'd love to know what you'll be trying next? Happy Baking! : )

I first made this fudge at Christmas with my ten year old son to hand out as presents, and not one person has been negative about the results with the majority of people saying it's the best fudge they've ever tasted, and I totally agree!! I substituted the milk for Baileys, actually put 250ml in to add extra flavour ;) and found it one of the easiest fudge recipes I'd ever made. I found on the second batch that using soft brown sugar worked just as well for those who struggle with the demerara option!

Carnation says:
Hi Emma, WOW this sounds utterly divine! So glad you love the recipe! : )

I made fudge today tastes really great but don't know why it was too soft I even measured with sugar thermometer.any comments

Carnation says:
Hi Shilpa, sounds like if you hit the magic number on the temperature it will be the beating at the final stage which you might need to do for longer to make it thicker and set more firmly. See our pudcast for more tips http://carnation.co.uk/Pudcasts/Category/20/Sweets

My first attempt at making this fudge it turned out more like tablet, all my family liked it though. Never one for giving up I made it second time around and its scrumptious. It is tricky though getting the timings right as I dont have a sugar thermometer.

I made this today but i had to use my microwave as my hob is broken, it turned out really well! I just took it out and mixed it up every minute and its really good! Also very easy :)

Carnation says:
Hi Suze, great stuff! Thats a new one on us in the Carnation Kitchen! Well done!

hi im just wondering can i use normal sugar/brown sugar or do i have to use demerara sugar?

Carnation says:
Hi Lauren, we like the flavour and texture that you get from using Demerara but you can use soft brown sugar if you don't have Demerara.

Didn't have any Demerara Sugar but used dark brown sugar - simply yummy and so smooth.

Carnation says:
Sounds delish Trudi!

My first attempt at making this fudge and although very slightly grainy in texture - it looks and tastes fantastic!! I will certainly be making more.

Hi, I have tried this so many times and it just will not work for me i have followed the recipe, its so grainy and tastes like sugar! no matter how long i take trying to get the sugar to melt (half an hour last night) i can still feel grains in the bottom of the pan?? Please help

Carnation says:
Hi Nicky, hmm have you watched our pudcast - this might help? Make sure that you don't overbeat the mixture at the end as this is really what develops the grainy texture....http://carnation.co.uk/Pudcasts/Category/20/Sweets

Great recipe this was my 3rd try of making fudge, well they do say third time lucky.
May have over beaten it a little but know for next time. cant wait to try some different flavours!!!!

Carnation says:
Hi Sara, practice makes perfect as our Mum's always said! Well done! Which flavour will you go for next?

Can I use Light Evaporated Milk for this?

Carnation says:
Hi Caroline, the recipe needs Condensed Milk not Evaporated Milk - but if you prefer you can use our Light Condensed Milk which works just fine. Do not use Evaporated Milk for this recipe.

I have just started making fudge and have made this one and the chocolate one from Carnation and both turned out absolutely perfect and were loved by family and friends. Thanks for the great recipes....

Carnation says:
You're very welcome Delores! So glad you like them!

Hiya just made the fudge, waiting for it to cool how long does it take? Should I put it in the fridge? Not sure if I over beat it think it might be a bit grainy. X

Carnation says:
Hi Sara, takes about 30 minutes at room temperature - you don't need to chill it. Only beat it until its thickening up - see our pudcast for more tips http://carnation.co.uk/Pudcasts/Category/20/Sweets

I made this about an hour ago and it's still very soft. I'm getting the feeling that I didn't get it hot enough.... is it too late for me to reboil?

Carnation says:
Hi Alexandra, sounds like you're right... You can try to reboil the mixture - just make sure you watch it like a hawk as it will catch more easily this time and turn a deeper toffee colour and taste. Best of luck! Alternatively roll the unset fudge into balls and dip in chocolate?

I was quiet apprehensive to make this after reading quite a lot of negative feed back. I followed your step by step instructions and found it all very straight forward, I did use a sugar thermometer and could not get it to your suggested temperature, the highest I got it was 110c. My fudge looks just like the picture, I'm really pleased with the results.

Carnation says:
Hi Rachel, great stuff! We love a happy ending! :0)

HI IM FROM SRILANKA? CN I KNW WT IS DEMERARA SUGAR? CN I USE CASTOR SUGAR FOR FUDGE

Carnation says:
Hi Fazla, we would not advise using caster sugar - demarara is light brown and has a coarse crystal so it gives good texture and flavour to the fudge.

This was absolutely great! Although it wasn't as thick as the picture in step three, it turned out perfect. It wasn't grainy at all and I found that it had the perfect texture. I would rate this ridiculously easy as I made it in the same time it suggested. (please change the rating). I love it and I will surely make it again, as my family and friends thought it was great. Thanks for such an awesome recipe that turned out delish, and I will surely follow more of your recipes for making excellent dishes.

Carnation says:
Hi Kim! So glad you liked it and found it so easy! Perhaps we ought to take a vote on what rating it should be?

Have tried to make but it just ended up as a big block of something tat tasted nothing like fudge!! Please help!!!!

Carnation says:
Hi Liddy, sounds like it got too hot! Check out our pudcast link and for best results always check the temperature with a sugar thermometer.

I was so disappointed with this recipe. The demerara sugar would not melt. Eventually I moved on to step two but it came to temperature (I was using a thermometer) much quicker than the recipe suggested. I took it off the heat and now it's cooling in the tin but I can see sugar crystals and it's nothing like fudge in texture.

Carnation says:
Hi Rebecca - you do need to be quite patient with the steps in this or it will go very grainy as you've discovered. Make sure you use a non-stick pan and keep the mixture moving over a gentle to moderate heat in the first stage. Only bring up to the boil once all the sugar has completely dissolved. All hobs and pans are different so the timings are just a guide. Once its reached temperature, cool it slightly then beat until thick. Don't give up - just takes a little practice, we're sure you'll be a fudge pro very soon!

I'm eleven and loads of people have said wonderful comments about it. Thanks for the recipe

Carnation says:
Hi Macie, well done you! You're very welcome :) happy cooking!

I totally failed at it! When I was boiling it, and the sugar thermometer only showed 105°C, the mass was already so thick that it started burning and I had to take it off the heat. I then stirred it for 15min (Which was one of the most painful moments in my life, because the wooden stick really scratched up my skin) and poured it in a tin. It was still shiny and I think the fudge didn't even think of getting hard and crumbly. So please help me! The product that I got is just sticky and actually has nothing to do with fudge! How do you get the mass to heat up to 116°C with our burning?

Thank you

PS: You should change it from "Ridiculously easy" to "Hard" or add more information and tips.

Carnation says:
Hi Friedemann, hope your arm has recovered! Not quite sure what went wrong here. It is only the temperature and the beating that make the difference. Did you use a non-stick pan? It's really important to constantly stir the mixture while melting and up to the boiling point. Once boiling stir occasionally. If the mixture is hot enough then when you start to beat the mixture and it cools it will reach a point when it starts to set in the pan. Best of luck!

I've made batches and batches of this this December. In one batch I replaced 100ml of the milk with Baileys and cooked as normal - absolutely delicious and just has the taste of Baileys without tasting alcoholic. Now going to try adding peanut butter...

Just making fudge using double cream instead of milk. Let you know how it turns out.

Made this and adde a handful of mini marshmallows & vanilla paste. excellent

I have just made this fudge using a thermometer - I then added 3 tablespoons Bailey's and beat it - but it hasn't set enough to cut it into squares - help please?

Carnation says:
Hi Jane, try beating the fudge a little longer and adding only 2 tablespoons of baileys.

I want to make baileys fudge, if I substituted some of the milk for baileys do you think that would work?

Carnation says: Hi Amanda, try stirring in about 3tbsp of baileys just towards the end of the beating stage, but while its still soft. There is no need to substitute the milk.